Why the message of the GP Forward View may not be getting through

9 June 2017

By David Colin-Thomé

General practice over the last few years, despite continuing to provide over 80% of all the clinical consultations in the NHS, has seen its workload hugely increased and its actual share of NHS finances reduced. Announcing the GP Forward View in 2016, Simon Stevens, chief executive since April 2014 of NHS England, said he was “openly acknowledging” the problems and acting on them.
 
We have a GP service which optimally needs to deliver on first point of contact care, continuous person and family focused care, care for all common health needs, management of chronic disease, referral and coordination of specialist care, care of the health of the population as well as the individual (Chambers and Colin-Thomé: Doctors Managing in Primary Care – International Focus 2008).
 
General practice is commendably still the most popular and the clinical service most highly ranked by the Care Quality Commission. This is despite increasing pressure and stresses that threaten its sustainability.
 
All practices small or large, rural or urban, successful or vulnerable need to deliver on that range of services. They may deliver by working either singly or by cooperating with other practices.
 
If a multi-practice, each practice may by agreement only deliver some of these services themselves, with the proviso their patients will receive the full range facilitated or provided by the larger organisation.
 
The current programme to introduce pharmacists into general practice to help with the increasingly pressurised service, needs similarly to be cognisant of local needs and match them with pharmacists with the appropriate skill to meet those needs. It may be appropriate for the pharmacist to be employed at the larger GP organisation level and make them available for individual practices.
 
Other staff needed in general practice, such as physiotherapists, could be similarly employed. Variation in funding to and by practices will need to be decided locally. The role of the larger GP organisation has become enormously significant in the modern context.
 
General medical practice’s heritage, strength and popularity with its patients have been earned by being local to its community and offering continuity of care. These virtues must be preserved and to fulfil the potential of general practice as a local provider and as a service that can shape and transform the NHS, it must be concomitantly small and large – small as an essential element of local social capital and large to be of strategic importance. The ongoing relationship between the practice and the larger GP or broader primary care organisation is fundamental.
 
NHS England is completely committed to major support for general practice but to avoid confusion, duplication and yet enhance support, a rationalisation of various national programmes is essential.
 
Within the umbrella of the GP Forward View, there are numerous programmes, some like those for access, vulnerable practices and resilience, confusingly overlapping and others (like the clinical pharmacists programme) addressing discrete issues of workforce and organisation.
 
The aims of these programmes are all worthwhile and pulling in broadly the same direction, but the existence of multiple programmes with separate funding arrangements is likely to induce piecemeal and siloed working.
 
How do these services aimed at individual practices relate to the larger organisations to which an estimated three-quarters of English general practices belong?
 
GP federations and the primary care home sites see developing, enthusing and enhancing local general practice as an essential part of their broader provider responsibility. Could these larger organisations be the optimal focus for GP support and where all support programmes are synergised?
 
There is an apparent disconnect between the vision and operational reality of the GP Forward View, which was expressed in recent complaints by GP professional bodies that funding does not appear to be reaching the service.
 
This is a pity because the GP Forward View promotes a vision many GPs would sign up to: individual practice working as part of a larger local organisation – a partnership of two equals. Both clinically led, population responsible, patient and community focused but with differing attributes that together can greatly enhance the offer to patients, public and the NHS.
 
Professor David Colin-Thomé is chair of PCC, a former national director of primary care with the Department of Health and honorary visiting professor at Manchester Business School.

For information about PCC’s support for primary care development, contact enquiries@pcc-cic.org.uk

 
Support updates Our news

Latest News

Changes to patient registration requirements

21 August 2017

From 2 October 2017, GPs will need to complete all new patient registrations using the new family doctor services registration (GMS1) form. The revised GMS1 form contains the same information as the current GMS1 form, as well as a supplementary questions section for overseas patients. Copies of the new form will be delivered directly to GP practices ahead of the 2 October 2017 date. Should any practice require further forms after that delivery, please order these from the primary care service England portal. The form can also be downloaded from the NHS Choices website.

Read More

Commissioning of end of life care for people with a learning disability

21 August 2017

People with a learning disability are more likely to experience poor general health and have high levels of unmet physical and mental health needs, including end of life care. NHS England has published guidance to help commissioners, providers and social care staff to improve palliative and end of life care for this group.

Read More

Effective negotiation: tapping in to your natural resources

21 August 2017

In this interactive, one-day training event we will discover how to make the best of a skill that we possess naturally and yet rarely use to best effect – negotiation.

Successful negotiation is a tool used by all successful professionals – in fact, it can be said that whenever we are with or in contact with other people there is implicitly a process of negotiation taking place.

So negotiation is not some kind of magic or skill for special situations – it is something that we should become more aware of doing, and therefore do more effectively. Used well, other people will appreciate your skills as a negotiator because they will benefit too. Good negotiators assist others to get what they want, while also meeting their own agenda and needs. It’s a true win-win!

The workshops will be held on 5 October in London, 12 October in Birmingham and 2 November in Manchester.

Read More

NHS health check 40-64 dementia pilot research findings

21 August 2017

A report from Alzheimer’s UK summarises the findings from a pilot project into the effectiveness of dementia risk reduction messaging in NHS health checks. It found that the pilot project showed promise in shifting public awareness and understanding of dementia risk with 75% of participants recalling the advice on dementia risk and 80% reporting that the advice would change their behaviour.

Read More

Involvement of people with experience of mental illness in CCG commissioning

21 August 2017

A report from think-tank Rethink finds that despite recommendations set out over a year ago in the five year forward view for mental health, little is known about the extent to which CCGs are involving people with experience of mental illness in the commissioning of mental health services. The research also reveals that most CCGs do not have clear plans for the co-production of mental health services and that the difficulty in prioritising this is due to pressure on resources and workload.

Read More